Previous page(s)

Main menu

End of this section

Next section

2.2 Premodification

The term premodification consists of the prefix pre-, denoting something that comes before in space or in time, and modification. The Longman Dictionary of Applied Linguistics (19) defines modification, modifier as follows: "a word or group of words (modifiers) which gives further information about (modifies) another word or group of words (head). Modifiers before the head are called premodifiers, modifiers after the head are called post-modifiers". The two processes are called premodification and postmodification respectively. The fact that this definition is generic — speaking, as it does, of "word or group of words" — points to the presence of premodification in English at various levels. It can be found at the level of adjective phrase (e.g. "very tired", where very premodifies tired), and at the level of verb phrase (e.g. "was getting" where the head is the verb form getting). Another, and last, level is the noun phrase (as in door knob) where the head is a noun.

2.2.1. Premodifiers of nouns

Premodification can consist of: (20)

a) One or more adjectives — a very frequent case in English:

1) He has rented a delightful cottage

where delightful premodifies the noun cottage (the adjective delightful gives further information about the cottage).

Example (1) is very simple and anyone could provide many more like it, with other adjectives. There are more complex cases where the premodifying adjectives are more than one. No limitations exist about the number. (21) The problem here is what order the adjectives should follow. Some grammar books give examples like

2) There was a round, green spot on the carved, wooden Japanese screen

to facilitate the memorisation of the order (both, all - the - ordinal number - cardinal number - general judgement - mental judgement - measurement - age or temperature - shape - colour - verb participle form - material - origin, nationality). (22)

Some studies suggest that in most cases the sequence goes from "less factual" to "more factual":

3) He was a pleasant, handsome, tall, Swedish boy.

Pleasant and handsome are largely subjective, tall is more factual and Swedish is totally factual — in the sense that people can be "more or less tall" but not "more or less Swedish": they are either Swedish or some other nationality. Technically, we say that tall is a gradable adjective and Swedish is a non-gradable adjective: there are various degrees of tallness, but not of "Swedishness". (23)

In their classification of noun premodifiers Leech and Svartvik (24) consider present and past participles as distinct from adjectives. Their example is:

4) He has rented a crumbling cottage

Most grammars do not keep them apart but include them among adjectives in general.

b) An adverb premodifying the noun. This case is not so frequent as with adjectives, but a few examples can be found:

5) His far-away cottage

6) The after effects

c) The so-called classifying genitive. A few examples:

7) His fisherman's cottage

8) A user's manual

9) A learner's dictionary

If we compare these with:

7a) His uncle's cottage

8a) Mr Brown's manual

9a) My brother's dictionary

we can see that in (7, 8, 9) we are talking about a type of cottage, manual or dictionary; in (7a. 8a, 9a) we are talking about specific objects and their owners. In (7) his premodifies the whole noun phrase fisherman's cottage, in (7a) his premodifies uncle only.

The following example contains both a possessive genitive and a classifying genitive and can help to make the difference clear:

10) John's doctor's degree

Doctor premodifies degree and John is the owner of the doctor's degree.

d) One or more nouns.

This very important type of premodification is called aggettivazione nominale and consists in "The use of one or more nouns that specify another and function as adjectives of it" (25).

2.2.2. Premodification by nouns

There are several types:

a) Head premodified by one noun:

This is the simplest case:

11)Tax evasion

12) bicycle chain

When the premodifier consists of one noun we can find:

If two words merge into one, we very frequently find that the sequence has acquired a new meaning, that does not reflect the original values of the components (for instance, a paperback is not a back but a book). In this case we should speak of compounding (a lexical process) rather than of premodification (a syntactic process).

The use of hyphens is often irregular and some words can be spelt in three different ways:

13a) head master

13b) head-master

13c) headmaster

a1) The premodifier is a plural noun

A plural noun used as a premodifier is normally in the singular form: (26)

14) trouser pockets

This applies not only when the noun is usually plural (like trousers) but also when the reference is to a number of objects; for example:

15) picture gallery (where more than just one picture is exhibited)

16) shoe shop (with several pairs of shoes on sale).

However, there are cases where the plural form remains, as in: (27)

17) sports car

18) customs officer

a2) the noun modifiers are preceded by an adjective

The noun phrase can be further expanded by multiple premodification; a frequent case is the presence of an adjective before the modifier. There are two possibilities; in cases like:

19) The French Lieutenant's Woman

20) The Good Housekeeping Journal

the adjectives premodify only the noun they precede: in (19) the Lieutenant is French, not the Woman (compare: The lieutenant's French woman); in (20) the housekeeping is qualified as good, not the journal. Whereas in:

21) A long car journey

22) the French film industry

the adjective premodifies the head and its modifier; in (21) the journey is long, not the car; in (22) the industry is French (and so are the films, as a consequence, but we are talking about the French industry of films, not about the industry of French films). The wrong interpretations are excluded on the basis of our knowledge of the world. This applies to the following pair of examples:

23a) An electric can opener

23b) Electric shock treatment

In (23a) electric premodifies the whole noun phrase can opener (we know that electric cans do not exist). In (23b) electric premodifies shock only.

A phrase like

24) Recent book reviews

is ambiguous (out of its appropriate context) because it may mean either Reviews of recent books or Recent reviews of books — the latter implying that the books might not be recent.

a3) A premodifying adjective is further premodified by an adverb

25) Badly designed Scandinavian furniture.

b) The premodifier is a proper noun

Examples are:

26) London airport

27) Brighton Technical College

28) Faber books

c) The head is premodified by co-ordinated nouns

29) Communication and information sciences (the sciences of communication and the sciences of information)

30) a Jekyll and Hyde personality

31) a bread and butter letter

The last two examples contain metaphorical expressions.

d) The head is premodified by a noun that is premodified by another noun

32) police patrol car

33) car insurance certificate

e) Phrases with three or more modifiers.

34) Lancaster City Football Club supporters (the supporters of the club for football in the City of Lancaster).

35) The Los Angeles County General Hospital Shock Research Unit (unit of research on shock at the general hospital of the county of Los Angeles).

2.2.3. Semantic relationships between heads and modifiers

Heads and modifiers are connected in various ways as regards meaning. These relationships are relevant in order to understand the phrases containing premodifications. The following cases have been identified: (28)

a) the premodifier classifies the type or nature of the head

36) horror film

37) history book

38) conference room

39) a flower shop

This classification may refer to people as well:

40) a factory worker

b) The two referents are linked by a part-to-whole relationship (the head is a part of the modifier):

41) car key

42) table leg

If the premodifier is a person, the possessive case is used instead:

43) John's leg

c) the premodifier can be a place-name indicating:

- origin

44) a Sussex man

- location

45) London airport

46) Moscow stadium

47) Tate Gallery Exhibition

- the place to which a road leads

48) the Oxford road (29)

d) The premodifier shows what the referent of the head is made of:

49) a gold watch

50) a plastic raincoat

51) cotton socks

The noun gold refers to the substance the thing is made of, while the adjective golden is usually metaphorical:

52) a golden sunset (a sunset which is like gold)

e) The premodifier refers to the time when something happens or is used:

53) afternoon tea

54) evening dress

55) wartime activities

f) Reference can be made to size:

56) pocket chess-set

57) a pint mug

In terms of meaning, we can find:

- a delimitation of the field. Car key limits the semantic field of key by saying what type of key we are talking about. (30)

- the development of a new concept. In the case of road sign there is no separate reference to a road and a sign, but we think of a specific referent directly — a metal board with icons, words and/or numbers giving directions or information to drivers.

A problem — that is common to premodification, compounding, derivation and several other linguistic phenomena — concerns the freedom to have recourse to them. We just cannot use premodification in any case, i.e. with any word as premodifier and another as head (obviously assuming that a semantic relationship exists between the two).

This possibility is available only for noun phrases describing well-known referents and is barred for cases that are too specific or unusual.

For example,

58) an economics journal

is correct, but

58a) *an inflation journal (for: a journal with articles on inflation

is not, because inflation is a topic and not a general subject. A similar case is offered by

59) an astronomy book

59a) *a Venus book (for: a book about Venus)

Similarly,

60) a corner table

is a common expression, while

60a) *a corner girl (for: a girl sitting in the corner)

is not.

Previous page(s)

Main menu

Top of this section

Next section